You asked a judge for a domestic violence restraining order, and the judge said no. Now the other side wants you to pay their lawyer. Can that happen? Only in a narrow situation. Under California law, a judge may order you to pay only if the other side proves your request was frivolous or was filed solely to abuse, intimidate, or cause delay. A California Court of Appeal decision certified for publication on November 17, 2026 shows how strict that rule is.
The Short Answer: Losing Is Not Enough
A denied restraining order request does not, by itself, mean you pay the other side’s attorney’s fees. The law sets a high bar first. The person who won must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that your request was frivolous or that its only purpose was to abuse, intimidate, or cause unnecessary delay. “Preponderance of the evidence” means more likely true than not.
If the judge finds that bar was not met, the judge has no power to award those fees under this law. That is what the new ruling holds.
What Family Code Section 6344 Says
Domestic violence restraining orders in California come from the Domestic Violence Prevention Act. Family Code section 6344 controls who pays attorney’s fees and costs when a request is decided. It treats the two sides very differently:
- If the person who asked for the order wins, the court “shall” order fees and costs after notice and a hearing, when they are requested. That word makes the award required.
- If the person who asked loses, the court “may” order fees for the other side “only if” that side proves the request was frivolous or solely intended to abuse, intimidate, or cause unnecessary delay.
- Before ordering either side to pay, the court must first decide that the person who would pay has, or is reasonably likely to have, the ability to pay.
The gap between “shall” and “only if” is the point. The law does not want fear of a fee bill to stop people from asking for protection.
What Happened in the Case
The case is In re Marriage of Michael and Sara W., decided by the First Appellate District, Division Three (No. A174495). The opinion was filed on October 22, 2026, and certified for publication on November 17, 2026.
A former wife asked a San Francisco judge for a domestic violence restraining order against her former husband. She pointed to a physical incident in 2022 and to public Facebook posts he made about her. The judge granted a temporary order. After five half-day hearings, the judge denied the full restraining order. Even so, the judge kept limits on the father’s travel with their child and barred him from naming her in future social media or public posts.
The former husband then asked for his attorney’s fees as the winning side. The judge found he had not proved the request was frivolous or filed solely to abuse, intimidate, or cause delay. The judge awarded him $20,000 in fees and costs anyway.
Why the Court of Appeal Reversed the $20,000 Award
The Court of Appeal reversed the fee award. Its reasons are simple and worth knowing:
- California follows the “American rule.” Each side pays its own lawyer unless a statute or an agreement says otherwise.
- The words “only if” in section 6344 set a necessary condition. When that condition is not met, the court cannot award fees under that section.
- The trial judge found the condition was not met and named no other legal basis for the award, so the award was an abuse of discretion.
The former husband pointed out that the trial judge had said there was “a lot of abuse, intimidation, and unnecessary delay” in the larger picture. The appeals court said that is not the same finding the law requires. The statute asks whether the request was solely intended for those purposes. The court also noted that the trial judge had granted part of what the former wife asked for, including the temporary order and limits on the posts and travel.
What “Frivolous” and “Solely Intended” Mean in Practice
These words set a high bar. A request is not frivolous just because the judge was not convinced. A request is not “solely intended” to harass just because the case was bitter or the other side felt attacked.
In this case, the trial judge accepted that a physical incident happened and saw photo and video evidence of bruising. The judge also found the former wife’s testimony about how upset the posts made her “credible and persuasive.” The Court of Appeal said that evidence supported the finding that the request was not frivolous or filed only to harm. A request with real facts behind it, even one that does not succeed, is the kind the law protects.
What This Ruling Does Not Decide
This decision is about one fee rule, section 6344. In this case, the trial judge separately denied both sides’ requests for sanctions under Family Code section 271 and said it was not deciding need-based fees. The appeal did not decide whether either of those rules could apply in another case.
So the ruling does not mean a person who loses a restraining order request can never be ordered to pay anything. It means a judge cannot use section 6344 to shift fees unless its test is met. For more on fee rules in family court, see our posts on the deadline to ask for fees after winning a restraining order and when filing for contempt in a divorce can cost you fees.
Common Questions About Fees After a Denied Restraining Order
If my restraining order request is denied, do I automatically pay?
No. The other side must ask for fees, there must be notice and a hearing, and the other side must prove the request was frivolous or filed solely to abuse, intimidate, or cause delay. The court must also consider ability to pay.
Can social media posts be part of a restraining order request?
Yes. Courts look at many kinds of conduct, including posts. We explained this in an earlier post on social media posts and domestic violence restraining orders.
Is this ruling final?
It was certified for publication on November 17, 2026. Published decisions can still be reviewed by the California Supreme Court, so check the case status before relying on it.
What This Means for People Asking for Protection
If you honestly believe you need a restraining order, the possibility of losing should not, on its own, scare you into silence. California law protects good faith requests. At the same time, every request should rest on true facts and real evidence, because a request that is frivolous or filed only to harass can lead to a fee order.
When to Call Mines Law Firm
We handle auto accident injury claims, and are accepting clients for those. If you are injured in an auto accident, that is when you should call us at 888-700-0093.
Sources: In re Marriage of Michael and Sara W. (Cal. Ct. App., First Dist., Div. Three, No. A174495, filed October 22, 2026, certified for publication November 17, 2026); Family Code section 6344. Checked November 21, 2026.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING. This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Responsible attorney: Jasmine Mines (State Bar No. 331135), Mines Law Firm, 468 N. Camden Drive, Suite 200, Beverly Hills, CA 90210.