Skip to main content

Mines Law Firm

Hit by Falling Truck Cargo? Who Loaded It May Share Blame

Semi truck driving on a long two-lane highway

A ladder, a pallet, or a piece of machinery came off a truck in front of you, and now you are hurt. The trucking company says it did nothing wrong, and the driver blames whoever packed the load. Who is responsible when cargo causes a crash in California?

Here is the short answer. The truck driver and the trucking company have clear duties to secure and check the load. But a California Court of Appeal decision filed September 14, 2026 says the company that loaded the cargo cannot hide behind an old rule that puts all the blame on the trucking company. When someone outside the shipping deal is harmed, more than one business may share the fault.

What Happened in the New California Truck Cargo Case

The case is State of California ex rel. Department of Transportation v. Herc Rentals, Inc., decided by the First Appellate District, Division Five (case number A174303). Herc, an equipment rental company, loaded a large boom lift onto a flatbed truck for another company to haul to a buyer. The lift was loaded “undocked,” which means its arm was still raised.

The driver did not measure the height of the load because, as the court noted, he did not have a measuring tape that day. On the highway, the top of the lift hit an overpass. The bridge stood 15 feet, 1 inch above the road, while the loaded lift stood 15 feet, 6 inches. Caltrans sued for the damage to the bridge.

The trial court ruled that only the trucking company and its driver could be blamed, and it threw out the claim against Herc. The Court of Appeal reversed that ruling.

The Old Rule That Blamed Only the Trucking Company

Herc relied on a 1953 federal appeals case called United States v. Savage Truck Line, Inc. That case said the main duty to load cargo safely belongs to the carrier, meaning the trucking company. Under that rule, if a loading problem was easy to see, the carrier was liable even if the shipper had also been careless.

The California court said this all-or-nothing approach does not fit California’s comparative fault system, where blame can be split among everyone who was careless. The court also said no California case has ever used the rule against a “third party,” meaning someone outside the deal between the shipper and the trucking company. In the court’s words, such a person “has no opportunity to remedy the negligence.”

The court’s conclusion was direct: the rule “cannot be used to categorically shield a shipper from liability to a third party even though the shipper’s negligence contributed to or resulted in harm to that third party.”

Why Trucking Rules Do Not Excuse the Company That Loaded the Cargo

Herc also pointed to federal trucking safety rules and California Vehicle Code section 35250. That section sets a height limit of 14 feet for most vehicles and loads, and it says a vehicle or load taller than 13 feet, 6 inches may only use highways the owner of the vehicle considers safe. As the court described them, the federal rules say a driver may not operate a commercial truck unless the cargo is properly distributed and adequately secured.

The court agreed these rules put duties on the trucking company. But they “do not mention shippers,” and the court found nothing saying that one company breaking a rule means another company owed no care at all. California Civil Code section 1714 still applies. It makes everyone responsible for harm caused by a lack of ordinary care in managing their property or themselves.

California also has a separate rule for loads on the road. Vehicle Code section 23114 says a vehicle shall not be driven on a highway unless it is built, covered, or loaded to prevent its load from “dropping, sifting, leaking, blowing, spilling, or otherwise escaping from the vehicle.”

What This Means If Cargo Hurt You in Los Angeles

Freight moves through Los Angeles County every day, from big rigs near the ports to flatbeds on the freeways and work trucks on city streets. When a load falls, shifts, or hits something, the question of who is at fault may not stop at the driver.

Depending on the facts, these may each play a part:

  • The truck driver, who must check and secure the load before driving.
  • The trucking company that employed the driver.
  • The business that packed or loaded the cargo, such as a rental yard, a store, or a warehouse.

Keep the limits of this ruling in mind. The court did not find that Herc was careless. It reversed the ruling, so the claim against Herc goes back to the trial court. The case also involved damage to a bridge, not an injured driver. Every crash turns on its own facts.

Evidence to Save After a Falling Cargo Crash

Cargo cases often turn on details that can disappear quickly. The truck drives off, the debris is cleared, and the load is unloaded at the next stop. If you are able, or if someone can help you, try to save:

  1. Photos of the truck, the load, the straps or chains, and any debris on the road.
  2. Any company name, truck number, or phone number painted on the truck or trailer.
  3. Names and phone numbers of witnesses.
  4. The crash report number from the officer at the scene.

Our guide on how to get a CHP or LAPD crash report in Los Angeles explains how to request the report later. For more first steps after a crash with a large truck, see our post on essential steps after a big rig accident.

Questions People Ask About Falling Truck Cargo

Is the truck driver always at fault when cargo falls off?

No. California law puts clear duties on the driver and the trucking company, but the Herc Rentals decision says the company that loaded the cargo cannot use the old federal rule to escape a claim by an outside party. Fault can be shared.

What if the other driver’s insurance is too small to cover my injuries?

When more than one business may share fault, more than one source of payment may be in the picture. Our post on what happens when the other driver only has minimum coverage explains other options people often overlook.

Does this ruling apply to a pickup truck or a moving van?

The case involved a commercial flatbed and a rental company. Vehicle Code section 23114 applies to any vehicle on a highway, though, and Civil Code section 1714 applies to everyone. How the ruling applies to a smaller vehicle depends on the facts.

When to Call Mines Law Firm

We handle auto accident injury claims, and are accepting clients for those. If you are injured in an auto accident, that is when you should call us at 888-700-0093.

ATTORNEY ADVERTISING. This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Responsible attorney: Jasmine Mines (State Bar No. 331135), Mines Law Firm, 468 N. Camden Drive, Suite 200, Beverly Hills, CA 90210.

Post Tags :

About the Firm

Mines Law Firm is a leading personal injury law firm dedicated to protecting the people, not the powerful. The Firm takes pride in the fact that it does not represent insurance companies, hospitals, or other large corporations.

Recent Post