When representing yourself (pro per) in a criminal case, your presence at key court hearings is crucial. Missing a hearing could result in a bench warrant, legal disadvantages, or even automatic loss in some circumstances. However, not all hearings require your attendance. This guide explains which hearings you must attend, why some hearings don’t require your presence, and strategies to ensure you’re present when it matters most.
1. Which Hearings Must You Attend?
In criminal cases, California law guarantees your right to be present at most hearings directly impacting your rights, liberty, or the outcome of your case. These include:
A. Arraignment
- Purpose: You are formally informed of the charges against you and asked to enter a plea.
- Required Attendance: Yes.
- Why: It’s your first opportunity to respond to the charges. If you fail to appear, the court may issue a bench warrant.
B. Preliminary Hearing (Felony Cases)
- Purpose: Determines if there is enough evidence for the case to proceed to trial.
- Required Attendance: Yes.
- Why: This hearing directly impacts whether your case will move forward.
C. Trial (Jury or Bench)
- Purpose: The court determines your guilt or innocence.
- Required Attendance: Yes.
- Why: Trials determine your fate, making your presence essential.
D. Sentencing Hearing
- Purpose: The court imposes your punishment if found guilty.
- Required Attendance: Yes.
- Why: You have the right to address the court before sentencing (allocution).
E. Evidentiary Hearings
- Purpose: To resolve motions related to evidence, such as suppression hearings.
- Required Attendance: Usually.
- Why: These hearings can significantly impact your defense.
2. Which Hearings May Not Require Your Presence?
Not all criminal court proceedings require your attendance. Examples include:
A. Pretrial Conferences
- Purpose: Attorneys discuss procedural issues, plea offers, and trial readiness.
- Required Attendance: No, unless you are specifically ordered to attend.
- Why: These hearings focus on administrative matters rather than substantive decisions.
B. Motions Heard Without Testimony
- Purpose: The court decides legal motions (e.g., discovery requests or procedural matters).
- Required Attendance: Not always.
- Why: If the motions do not involve your testimony or significant decisions about your rights, your presence may not be necessary.
C. Post-Conviction Motions
- Purpose: Hearings on motions filed after conviction, such as motions to modify probation terms.
- Required Attendance: It depends. For minor modifications, the court may rule without requiring your presence.
3. How to Ensure Your Presence at Required Hearings
A. Notify the Court of Your Pro Per Status
- File a notice with the court indicating that you are representing yourself.
- Request that all hearing notices and documents be sent directly to you.
B. Request a Writ of Habeas Corpus Ad Prosequendum (If Incarcerated)
- If you are in custody and need to attend a hearing in another jurisdiction, file a motion requesting the court issue this writ to ensure your transportation.
C. Arrange Transportation (If Applicable)
- Coordinate with the jail or prison staff well in advance to ensure you are transported to court on time.
- File motions for transportation as early as possible, including all relevant hearing details.
D. Request a Virtual Appearance
- In cases where physical attendance isn’t possible or practical, request to appear via video conferencing.
- California courts increasingly allow virtual appearances, especially for procedural hearings.
E. Regularly Check Your Case Status
- Monitor your case online through court websites or by calling the clerk’s office. Ensure you’re aware of any changes in hearing dates or times.
F. Communicate With the Judge’s Clerk
- Contact the judge’s clerk to confirm your hearing details and discuss your attendance plans. While they cannot provide legal advice, they can clarify procedural requirements.
G. Set Up Alerts and Reminders
- Use a calendar app to track court dates and set multiple reminders.
- Ask family or friends to remind you of upcoming hearings.
H. Seek Temporary Assistance from Standby Counsel
- If the court has appointed standby counsel for your case, they may assist in ensuring you’re present for critical hearings.
4. Creative Ways to Ensure Your Attendance
A. Work With Advocacy Groups
- Organizations that support pro per litigants or incarcerated individuals can help you navigate the process and ensure your attendance.
B. Request an Inmate Advocate
- Many jails and prisons have inmate advocates who can assist with legal logistics, including transportation and communication with the court.
C. File Early Motions for Continuances
- If logistical barriers arise, request a continuance well in advance to avoid missing critical hearings.
D. Pre-Submit Statements
- For hearings where attendance is not mandatory, consider submitting written declarations or motions to ensure your voice is heard.
5. Consequences of Missing a Required Hearing
If you miss a required hearing, the court may:
- Issue a bench warrant for your arrest.
- Rule against you in your absence.
- Find you in contempt of court, which may result in fines or additional penalties.
6. Why Some Hearings Do Not Require Your Presence
Certain hearings focus on procedural or administrative matters that don’t directly affect your rights. For example:
- Discovery Hearings: These involve exchanges of evidence and may not require your input.
- Status Conferences: These address the case’s progress and procedural timelines, often involving only the attorneys or the court.
Conclusion
As a pro per litigant in a criminal case, ensuring your presence at court hearings is critical to protecting your rights and advancing your defense. While some hearings don’t require your attendance, most significant hearings do, especially those involving charges, evidence, or sentencing.
By proactively communicating with the court, filing necessary motions, and exploring creative solutions, you can overcome logistical barriers and ensure your participation. For additional guidance, consult court self-help resources or legal aid organizations.
***
Disclaimer: This information is provided for educational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. For personalized legal guidance on third-party insurance claims or related matters, consult with a qualified attorney familiar with the law in your jurisdiction.
