A prosecutor told a story about a pit bull during jury selection. He said he was trying to help jurors set aside their fears. On November 19, 2026, a California Court of Appeal published a ruling that the story broke the Racial Justice Act. The court vacated the convictions of all three men.
The short answer: words that compare a defendant to an animal can break this law, even if the prosecutor did not mean it that way. The court looks at the words used, not the speaker’s intent.
What the Racial Justice Act Says About Courtroom Language
The California Racial Justice Act is found in Penal Code section 745. Subdivision (a)(2) covers trial language. It is violated when, among others, an attorney in the case “used racially discriminatory language about the defendant’s race, ethnicity, or national origin, or otherwise exhibited bias or animus towards the defendant because of the defendant’s race, ethnicity, or national origin, whether or not purposeful.”
Subdivision (h)(4) defines racially discriminatory language. It includes language that, “to an objective observer, explicitly or implicitly appeals to racial bias.” The definition expressly includes “language that compares the defendant to an animal.”
The words “whether or not purposeful” matter. A person does not need to prove the speaker was racist. The defendant must prove the violation by a preponderance of the evidence, which means more likely than not.
The Case: People v. Diaz
In People v. Diaz (Sixth District Court of Appeal, No. H050849), three men were tried in Santa Clara County. The case came from a 2019 shooting at a meeting set up as a marijuana sale. One man was killed and another was wounded. In 2022, a jury convicted two defendants of murder with a robbery special circumstance, and all three of robbery and assault with a semiautomatic firearm.
The opinion was first filed on October 23, 2026. On November 19, 2026, the court modified it and certified it for publication. Justice Cynthia C. Lie wrote the opinion, and Acting Presiding Justice Grover and Justice Wilson joined it. The decision was unanimous.
What the Prosecutor Said About a Pit Bull Named Medusa
During jury selection, one prospective juror doubted she could be fair. To help her, the prosecutor described dog sitting for a pit bull. He said, “I knew her name was Medusa and she was a pit[]bull.” He added, “Medusa is going to tear my arm off, right?” His point was that he judged the dog before he met her.
Another prospective juror objected out loud: “I can’t sit here while [the prosecutor] compares the defendants to an animal. His analogy is not appropriate.” The trial judge said the judge did not see it that way. Later, in closing argument, the prosecutor called the case “a case about the food chain on the street.”
Why Intent Did Not Save the Analogy
The court accepted that the prosecutor may have had harmless reasons. It said it presumed the story came from his own life. But it explained that “the relationship the prosecutor posited by his dog sitter:pit bull analogy is one of master and potentially vicious beast.”
The court also noted that “countless other analogies could have similarly addressed bias without reinforcing it by reference to animals or animalistic behavior.” And it stated the rule plainly: “under the RJA, we examine the language employed by the prosecutor, not his intent or apparent good faith.”
The court judged the words the way a fair observer would. That observer knows that hidden bias exists. The court held that the prosecutor used racially discriminatory language during jury selection and closing argument, in violation of section 745, subdivision (a)(2).
What the Court Ordered
The court reversed the judgment. In its words, “Each defendant’s convictions and sentence are vacated and are legally invalid.” It sent the case back to the trial court for further proceedings under section 745, subdivision (a). The court described that as a remand to decide a remedy, which may include a new trial.
This is not a finding that the defendants are innocent. The court did not rule on most of the other trial errors the defendants raised, because the Racial Justice Act ruling resolved the appeal.
Limits Readers Should Know
- The court said the Racial Justice Act does not ban every reference to an animal in a courtroom.
- No defense lawyer objected at trial. The court excused that on this record. But its November 19 change to the opinion said other claims that were never raised at trial should not expect the same relief.
- The court said the “food chain” remarks in closing, standing alone, might not have been enough.
Those limits matter. A person reading this case should not assume every rough word at trial will undo a conviction. The facts and the trial record decide each claim.
Questions People Ask About the Racial Justice Act
Does the prosecutor have to be racist for this to apply?
No. Section 745, subdivision (a)(2) applies “whether or not purposeful.” In Diaz, the court focused on the words used, not the prosecutor’s motive.
Does it matter if no one objected at trial?
It can. The court held that these claims can be lost when no one objects. It excused that here for reasons specific to this case. Raising the issue at trial is the safer course.
Is this decision final?
The opinion was certified for publication on November 19, 2026. The time for further review may not have run, so check the case’s current status before relying on it.
Related reading on this site: the Racial Justice Act in very simple terms, why statewide data failed in one Racial Justice Act resentencing case, and what racial bias can mean for a criminal case. You can read the full opinion on CourtListener.
When to Call Mines Law Firm
We handle auto accident injury claims, and are accepting clients for those. If you are injured in an auto accident, that is when you should call us at 888-700-0093.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING. This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Responsible attorney: Jasmine Mines (State Bar No. 331135), Mines Law Firm, 468 N. Camden Drive, Suite 200, Beverly Hills, CA 90210.