You asked the court for mental health diversion, and the judge said no. Can a judge really do that when your diagnosis is not in doubt? The answer is yes. Under California law, a judge can deny diversion if the judge finds you would pose an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety if treated in the community. A Los Angeles case decided on November 17, 2026 shows how that test works.
What Mental Health Diversion Does
Mental health diversion lets a person charged with a crime get treatment instead of going straight through a criminal case. The rule is in Penal Code section 1001.36, and if the judge grants it, the case is put on hold while the person follows an approved treatment plan.
The time limits are set by the statute. Diversion can last up to two years for a felony and up to one year for a misdemeanor. If the person does well, the judge must dismiss the charges at the end. The arrest is then treated as if it never happened, with some exceptions the statute lists, such as applications to become a peace officer.
Two Separate Questions: Eligible and Suitable
The statute asks two different questions, and a person must pass both.
The first question is eligibility. A person is eligible when two things are true:
- A qualified mental health expert has diagnosed a mental disorder listed in the current Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, within the last five years.
- The disorder was a significant factor in the charged offense. The judge must presume that it was, unless there is clear and convincing evidence that it was not.
The second question is suitability. Here the statute lists four requirements. An expert must say the symptoms would respond to treatment. The person must agree to diversion and give up the right to a speedy trial. The person must agree to follow treatment. And the person must not pose an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety if treated in the community.
Some charges are never allowed into this program at all. The statute bars murder, voluntary manslaughter, rape, and several sex offenses, among others.
What “Unreasonable Risk of Danger” Means
This phrase does not mean any risk of any crime, because the statute borrows a definition from Penal Code section 1170.18. As the court explained in the new case, it means the risk that the person will commit one of a short list of very serious crimes, often called “super strikes.” That list includes murder and attempted murder.
So the real question is not whether the person might steal again. It is whether the judge believes the person is likely to commit one of those very serious crimes.
The statute also tells the judge what may be considered. The judge may look at the opinions of the prosecutor, the defense, and a mental health expert. The judge may also consider the treatment plan, the person’s history of violence and crime, the current charge, and any other factor the judge finds appropriate.
The Case: People v. Gardner
In People v. Gardner, the Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District, Division Four, upheld a Los Angeles County judge’s denial of diversion. The opinion was filed on November 17, 2026 and certified for publication.
The man was charged with robbery after he took a few items from a store and drew a machete when a clerk stood in his way. An expert said he had schizophrenia and substance use disorders. No one disputed that he was eligible.
The trial judge still denied diversion, for two reasons. First, the judge found he was unlikely to keep taking his medication, because he had stopped it soon after an earlier treatment program ended. Second, the judge found he posed an unreasonable risk to public safety, because his past crimes involved weapons such as a hammer, a screwdriver, an axe, and a machete, aimed at people.
Why the Appeals Court Agreed With the Judge
The Court of Appeal said the judge’s findings were supported by the evidence. The man had never been convicted of, or even charged with, a super strike, but the court said that did not settle the question here. Based on his recent pattern of using weapons against people, the judge could reasonably conclude that the next incident might end in a death.
The court also rejected the argument that past treatment setbacks can never count. It said a judge may consider whether a person is likely to stay on medication when deciding whether the person is likely to commit a super strike.
One more detail stood out in the opinion: the court noted that the defense expert’s report barely mentioned the man’s criminal history.
Lessons From the Ruling for a Diversion Request
This ruling does not change the statute, but it shows how a judge may apply its requirements in a real courtroom. A few points follow from the opinion itself:
- The danger question is about very serious future crimes, not about any future crime.
- A judge may look closely at how past crimes were committed, including whether a weapon was used against a person.
- A judge may consider whether treatment is likely to continue after supervision ends.
- An expert report that does not address the person’s history may carry less weight with the judge.
The opinion compared other cases where diversion was wrongly denied. In one, two professionals rated the person as low risk, there was no sign of access to weapons, and he had been out on bond for two years without trouble. Those facts were missing in Gardner.
Common Questions About Diversion Denials
Does a mental illness diagnosis guarantee diversion?
No. A diagnosis is only one part of eligibility, which is the first of two separate questions. The judge must also find the person suitable, and the statute says the judge “may, in its discretion” grant diversion.
Can a judge deny diversion without a past violent conviction?
According to Gardner, yes, if the evidence supports a finding that the person is likely to commit a super strike. A clean record of super strikes does not end the question.
Is this ruling final?
It was certified for publication when it was filed on November 17, 2026. Published decisions can still be reviewed by the California Supreme Court, so check the case status before relying on it.
What This Means for Families
If a loved one is seeking mental health diversion, the danger question may decide the outcome. The full history, the treatment plan, and how treatment will continue later all matter. Other recent rulings show how much depends on proven facts, including how upper term sentences depend on proven facts, why prosecutors must prove a person was on parole before a violation can be found, and when a judge may resentence without a change in the law.
When to Call Mines Law Firm
We handle auto accident injury claims, and are accepting clients for those. If you are injured in an auto accident, that is when you should call us at 888-700-0093.
Sources: People v. Gardner (Cal. Ct. App., Second Dist., Div. Four, No. B349188, filed November 17, 2026); Penal Code section 1001.36. Checked November 19, 2026.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING. This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Responsible attorney: Jasmine Mines (State Bar No. 331135), Mines Law Firm, 468 N. Camden Drive, Suite 200, Beverly Hills, CA 90210.